According to party line, neither
Beck nor
Geffen ever intended
Mutations to be considered as the official follow-up to Odelay, his Grammy-winning breakthrough. It was more like
One Foot in the Grave, designed to be an off-kilter, subdued collection of acoustic-based songs pitched halfway between psychedelic country blues and lo-fi folk. The presence of producer
Nigel Godrich, the man who helmed
Radiohead's acclaimed OK Computer, makes such claims dubious.
Godrich is not a slick producer, but he's no
Calvin Johnson, either, and
Mutations has an appropriately clean, trippy feel. There's little question that with the blues, country, psych, bossa nova, and folk that comprise it,
Mutations was never meant to be a commercial endeavor -- there's no floor-shaker like "Where It's At," and it doesn't trade in the junk culture that brought Odelay to life. Recording with his touring band -- marking the first time he has entered the studio with a live band -- does result in a different sound, but it's not so much a departure as it is a side road that is going in the same direction. None of the songs explore new territory, but they're rich, lyrically and musically. There's an off-the-cuff wit to the songwriting, especially on "Canceled Check" and "Bottle of Blues," and the performances are natural, relaxed, and laid-back, without ever sounding complacent. In fact, one of the nifty tricks of
Mutations is how it sounds simple upon the first listen, then reveals more psychedelic layers upon each play.
Beck is not only a startling songwriter -- his best songs are simultaneously modern and timeless -- he is a sharp record-maker, crafting albums that sound distinct and original, no matter how much they may borrow. In its own quiet, organic way,
Mutations confirms this as much as either
Mellow Gold or Odelay. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine, Rovi
